Wednesday, February 27, 2013

Are Price Controls the Answer? Netherlands Edition

This post is co-authored with Misja Mikkers, who is Director of Strategy and Legal Affairs at the Netherlands Healthcare Authority and is affiliated with Tilburg University, the Netherlands and Copenhagen Business School, Denmark.
In a previous post one of us (Gaynor) examined some evidence on whether price controls are effective in slowing the rate of growth of health care spending, and how they compare with competition in private markets. In this post we examine some evidence from the Netherlands that may bear on the matter. In the previous post a data point from the Netherlands was shown as part of an international comparison, but it’s worthwhile to examine the Netherlands experience a bit further. The Netherlands is particularly interesting because they have employed rate setting in health care and subsequently deregulated much of their health sector to allow prices to be market determined. The question of whether the end of rate setting and the introduction of competition raised or lowered health care costs and prices in the Netherlands is hotly debated.

The article by Steven Brill in Time also led also to a lot of discussion in the Netherlands. Rob Wijnberg (former editor of the important Dutch Newspaper NRC-next) tweeted, “brilliant article about the reasons why competition in health care doesn’t work" (, Feb 26, translation M. Mikkers). 

Health reform in the Netherlands has been gradual and has had a number of different elements. Initially competition in health insurance was introduced (with an individual mandate), while maintaining rate setting for providers. A partial and gradual deregulation of provider prices followed. For hospitals some services have been deregulated (this is called the B Segment) and some services remain under price controls (the A Segment). The proportion of services in the deregulated B Segment has increased over time. In 2005 8% of hospital services were in the B-segment. This percentage then increased to 20% and 30% in 2008 and 2009 respectively. In 2012 virtually all elective care (70% of hospital services) was in the B segment.

The figure below (source: Market Scan Hospital Market 2011, Netherlands Healthcare Authority [in Dutch]) shows the percentage change in hospital prices over time in the price controlled A Segment and deregulated B Segment. As can be seen, growth in the deregulated segment, where prices are market determined, is substantially lower from about 2006-2007 onwards. In fact, from about 2008-2009 to 2010-2011 prices were falling in the deregulated segment while they were still growing in the price controlled segment. This doesn’t necessarily mean that competition controls prices and rate setting does not (lots of other things could be going on), but neither do we see what we’d expect if rate setting was doing a superior job of controlling prices.
The next figure (below, source: CBS [Dutch Central Bureau of Statistics] ) shows the growth rate in hospital spending in the Netherlands in the period before rate deregulation (2001-2005) and after deregulation began (2006-2011). The average annual growth rates between the two periods are virtually indistinguishable. Again, this isn’t scientific proof that rate setting doesn’t control costs (either in general or in the Netherlands), but there’s no slam dunk for rate setting in the patterns that we observe. We may be able to see more interesting patterns in the future. By 2014 and 2015 virtually all prices for elective care will have been deregulated and all parties in the market will be fully exposed to the consequences of their (price) negotiations.  

In sum, the Netherlands is a good place to look for the effects of rate setting versus markets on prices and spending, since they have employed both. A quick look at some descriptive statistics doesn’t yield any slam dunks for rate setting. If anything, shifting to markets may have substantially reduced price growth. However, careful study will be required in order to draw firmer conclusions. Last, while we believe that there are lessons for the US from experiences in other countries (and vice versa), we do have to be cautious in making strong inferences across very different health care systems and societies.


  1. Great article. I've read that the Life Sciences and Health sector is becoming more and more important. In fact, these are one of the prosperous sectors! SIRE Life Sciences has written an article on this, see here - They provide a lot of interesting articles about the Life Sciences industry, you can find them on the website -

    1. Welcome to ASYLUM FINANCIAL ENTERPRISE PLC. Are you in a financial mess or do You need funds to start your own business? or start a nice business? Are you a business man or woman? Do you have a low credit score and you will find it hard to get Capital loan from local banks / other financial institutions? Loan or funding for any reason: Contact us via E-mail:

  2. Electricity is a necessity, so whatever companies charge is what the population has to pay.Business owners are always looking for ways to expand profit margins. It’s important to reduce expenses in a way that doesn't damage the quality of service or products. compare electricity rates houston

  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

  4. Do you need a quick long or short term loan with a relatively low interest rate as low as 3%? We offer Xmas loan, business loan, personal loan, home loan, auto loan,student loan, debt consolidation loan e.t.c. no matter your score, If yes contact us via Email: Fill The Loan Application Form Below Name............ Amount Needed........ Duration.......... Country............ Monthly income....... Age............. Phone Number........ Sex ................. Email................Business Plan/Use Of Your Loan:....... Apply now on this email Warm Regards Dr Purva Sharegistry

  5. Do you need Loan to pay off your debt and start a new life? You have come to the right place were you can get FUNDED at a very low interest rate. Interested people/company should please contact us via email for more details.

    Full name:
    Date of birth (yyyy-mm-dd):
    Marital status:
    Amount Needed:
    Zip/postal code:
    Phone number:
    Monthly Income:
    via us;


    We have provided over $500 million in business loans to over 15,000 business owners just like you. We use our own designated risk technology to provide you with the right business loan so you can grow your business. Our services are fast and reliable, loans are approved within 72 hours of successful application. We offer loans from a minimum range of $5000 to a maximum of $20 million.

    We Offer:
    * Business Loans
    * Personal Loans or Signature Loans
    * Arrangements to Borrow from $5,000.00 up to $20,000,000
    * Choose between 1 to 10 years repayment period.
    * Choose between monthly and annual repayment plan.
    * Flexible loan terms and conditions applied.
    * Interest rates as low as 2%.

    We are certified and your privacy is 100% safe with us. Worry no more about your loans or finances.

    Contact us today via:

    Get your instant loan approval

  7. Do you need a loan at 3% to pay your bills or start up a business of
    your own? If yes ,contact US with this following details... GLOBAL SOLUTION FINANCE COMPANY

    (1)Full Name
    (2)Loan Amount Needed
    (5)Phone numbers
    Email Us:
    Tell : +919205335862

    Best Regards,

  8. Actually picture is the presentation of some one’s feelings; it provides the lesson to the viewers.


    I’m Henry Donald by name. I live in CANADA, i want to use this medium to alert all loan seekers to be very careful because there are scam everywhere. Few months ago (which November 2016) I was financially strained, and due to my desperation I was scammed by several online lenders. I had almost lost hope until a friend of mine referred me to a very reliable lender called HENRY LOANS COMPANY FROM USA who lend me an unsecured loan of $50,000 under 3hours without any stress. If you are in need of any kind of loan just contact him now via:( I‘m using this medium to alert all loan seekers because of the hell I passed through in the hands of those fraudulent lenders. And I don’t wish even my enemy to pass through such hell that I passed through in the hands of those fraudulent online lenders,i will also want you to help me pass this information to others who are also in need of a loan once you have also receive your loan from HENRY LOANS COMPANY FROM USA, i pray that God should give him long life. Email;
    They offer all kind of categories of loan they
    Short term loan (5_10years)
    Long term loan (20_40)
    Media term loan(10_20)
    They offer loan like
    Home loan............., Business loan........ Debt loan .......
    Student loan..........,Business start up loan
    Business loan....... , Company loan.............. etc
    Email..........( ).

  10. Hello Everybody,
    My name is Mrs.Irene Query. I live in Philippines and i am a happy woman today? and i told my self that any lender that rescue my family from our poor situation, i will refer any person that is looking for loan to him, he gave me happiness to me and my family, i was in need of a loan of $150,000.00 to start my life all over as i am a single mother with 2 kids I met this honest and GOD fearing man loan lender that help me with a loan of$150,000.00 US. Dollar, he is a GOD fearing man, if you are in need of loan and you will pay back the loan please contact him tell him that is Mrs.Irene Query, that refer you to him. contact Mr Mark Harry,via email:( Thank you.